Don’t Call It a Smartphone Ban! Teach Self-Regulation Skills in Schools! Kids Need it. 

I know this can be a controversial topic, but this is just one perspective to many negative posts I have seen. Phone policies can be an opportunity.

Photo generated by ChatGPT 4

In today’s digital age, navigating the complexities of smartphone usage in schools is a significant challenge for educators and leaders. But what if we reframed the narrative? Instead of labeling it a “smartphone ban,” let’s focus on something more impactful: teaching self-regulation skills that students can carry with them for life. At Port Clinton City Schools, we’ve embraced this philosophy, and the results speak for themselves.

This approach, driven by our teachers and supported by school leadership, reflects our commitment to empowering teacher-led initiatives, is not about taking something away; it’s about giving students the tools they need to thrive in an increasingly connected world. Our own counselors have identified self-regulation as one of the primary skills needed for students’ success. In fact, one student expressed gratitude, sharing how the policy eased their mind knowing no one could send them something they’d feel pressured to check. It’s a powerful reminder that how we communicate a policy is as critical as the policy itself. Limiting something is not always a penalty, but at times, perhaps a gift. We view it as an opportunity as our state demanded policy use.

Additionally, my work, writing for the Apple Education community and presenting on how to use the settings and tools within devices to model and support self-regulation, has highlighted practical strategies like time limits on social media and games, Do Not Disturb Mode, timers, reminders, jouranl, and other built-in features. These tools empower students to manage their tech use in meaningful ways, demonstrating that self-regulation can be both taught and supported effectively.

We must also acknowledge the mounting evidence on the harm social media sites can inflict on the developing minds and mental health of students. Reports consistently show that unregulated use of social media correlates with increased anxiety, depression, and focus issues. These findings underscore the urgent need to teach and model healthy tech habits in schools.

Parental concerns about student safety are valid, but it’s important to understand that our phone regulation policies are designed with care and thoughtfulness, not as punitive measures. Schools today are equipped with numerous safety features, including School Resource Officers (SROs), secure entry systems, and emergency protocols. We also have a dedicated team of counselors, compassionate teachers, and strong leadership to ensure student well-being. Students are allowed to have their phones, during lunch but not during class. This regulation isn’t about restricting freedom but fostering engagement and focus. Our classrooms are equipped with incredible devices and technology to enhance learning, and our teachers work tirelessly to create engaging, interactive lessons. By keeping phones away during instructional time, we’re helping students develop the skills they need to focus and succeed in a world full of distractions.

Here are three actionable steps to implement this approach effectively in your school:

1. Model Self-Regulation for Students

Leadership is about setting the example. Show students what self-regulation looks like by practicing it yourself. Whether it’s designated tech-free zones in staff meetings or modeling focus during class observations, students take their cues from us. When they see adults navigating technology with balance, they’re more likely to emulate it.

2. Teach the Why

Don’t just implement rules–educate students on the importance of self-regulation. Incorporate lessons on mindfulness, focus, and the impact of constant connectivity into advisory periods or classroom discussions. Help students understand that self-regulation isn’t just a school skill; it’s a life skill that will serve them in college, the workplace, and beyond. Involve students in the process.

3. Celebrate Success Stories

Highlight the positive outcomes of your efforts. Share stories like the student who felt relief knowing their social circle couldn’t bombard them with distractions during the day. Acknowledge classrooms where focus and engagement have noticeably improved. When students and staff see the tangible benefits, buy-in becomes easier.

Leading change is often about how we frame it. By focusing on teaching self-regulation rather than banning devices, we shift from punitive measures to empowering practices. This isn’t just a win for students; it’s a win for the culture of our schools.

So let’s lead with purpose, teach with vision, and model the skills that will shape the leaders of tomorrow. Smartphones may be pervasive, but the ability to regulate their use is a skill worth mastering.

Always forward,

Kelly

I would like to speak at your event!

Order Kelly’s books, Along Came a Leader and Unthink Before Bed: A Children’s Book on Mindfulness for your personal library.

Educator, Author, Keynote Speaker
Twitter: @kellycroy
Instagram: @kcroy
Website: kellycroy.com and wirededucator.com
Podcast: The Wired Educator Podcast
and of course: Facebook.

Sign-up for Kelly’s newsletter here.